The Mechanisms That Remain
From P2 to Austrian dossiers: comparing appointments, information flows and financial leverage with VERHO
A P2 receipt. Three dates surrounding an appointment. News of a seized video withheld for more than a month. Italian and Austrian records show how certain ways of exercising power recur over time.
A handwritten name: Berlusconi Silvio. A total: 100,000 lire. A date at the bottom: 26 January 1978. These details can be read on a reproduction of a P2 lodge membership receipt. Understanding what they mean requires further documents: records that make it possible to distinguish membership, financing, a debt and control over a decision.
This trail leads to a very concrete question: who can get close to the place where decisions are made, who gains an office and who can learn a decisive piece of information? Antimafia Austria's VERHO project compared Italian P2 documents with the findings of an Austrian parliamentary inquiry. The question was straightforward: does the same way of operating a lever of power reappear years later?
In the cases examined, the answer is yes for two precisely defined functional cores: informal intervention in appointments and filtering the circulation of relevant information. People, institutions and means of communication change. The observed function can still be recognised. Italian financial documents also help show how money, access and the ability to influence decisions may intersect, while preserving the distinct meaning of every document.
01 / AppointmentsOne appointment, three dates, one personal channel
On 11 January 2016, Georg Angerer approached Michael Kloibmüller to request the promised support for the leadership of Salzburg's LVT. The appointment took effect on 1 November. On 6 December, a message of thanks followed after the appointment decrees had been collected. The Austrian dossier preserves three steps: request, appointment, thanks. The report includes the case among those in which the preferred candidate obtained the position.[2]
In the Italian records, the 1984 Anselmi report reconstructs Licio Gelli's efforts concerning appointments to the top ranks of state bodies. On page 80, PDF page 88, interventions in favour of Orazio Giannini's appointment are expressly recorded; in Raffaele Giudice's case, a personal channel reaching the responsible minister is described. The page distinguishes these elements from claims in which Gelli credited himself with other successes.[1]
The common core is recognisable: a preferred candidate, a privileged intermediary and an intervention entering an appointment procedure through a personal channel. In VERHO terminology, the finding concerns the appointment component of B05-S07. The organisational forms differ: affiliation and contacts matter in the P2 case; in the Austrian case, the focus is on the political and personal communications preserved in the records.
The significance of the finding remains clear precisely because counterexamples are retained. In the succession to General Mino, Gelli's preference for Santovito did not coincide with Corsini's eventual appointment. The Austrian report did not conclude that a professionally unqualified person had been favoured, nor did it specifically examine the wider Hallein-Netzwerk. A candidate's success does not, by itself, establish every internal cause of the decision.
For this reason, the match at the functional core is not automatically extended to B05-S01, which requires control of a specific decision-making node and, in its operational formulation, the subsequent use of that office. Influencing access and demonstrating how the appointee later made decisions are two separate steps.
- Preferred person
- Personal channel
- Intervention in appointment
02 / InformationThe video exists. Those who need to know are left out
The 2023 Austrian report reconstructs how the WKStA, the prosecution office specialising in economic crime and corruption, was not informed that the video under investigation had already been seized. It specifies that the WKStA had also ordered that it be obtained. On the basis of the communications quoted, the report assesses a period of non-disclosure exceeding one month as knowingly tolerated, in connection with the one-sided public presentation of investigative success.[3]
The footage had already been obtained. The decisive issue had become the flow of information: who knew, who should have been told and who remained excluded? This is an easily understood lever of power: a body may have the authority to act yet still lack access to the information needed to exercise it.
The P2 report describes intelligence notes about Gelli that were not forwarded to Rome. On page 64, PDF page 72, it reproduces an explanation linking the blockage to a superior's disagreement and the threat of a disciplinary or service-related measure. In subsequent pages, the commission also interprets the broader conduct of the agencies as a protective information barrier.[1]
The function recurs: available information remains behind an access barrier and fails to reach the competent recipient in time. That is the connection with withholding relevant material in B01-S04. The shift from intelligence services to the police and prosecution is an institutional adaptation: duties, motives and consequences do not thereby become identical.
The Austrian report also sets out alternative explanations from those involved, concerning separate investigations, uncertainty and expectations about the internal circulation of information. The comparison preserves these explanations alongside the commission's assessment. The recurrence of the function is documented; the characterisation of each act and the extent of its effects remain specific to each case.
- Available information
- Access filter
- Uninformed authority
03 / Italian recordsItaly's P2: read the receipt before constructing a narrative
One name.
One amount.
One purpose.
Reading begins with the visible details. Banking transactions and bills of exchange belong to other trails that must be reconstructed separately.
The reproduction published in this article bears the heading R. L. Propaganda 2, the number 104, the name Berlusconi Silvio and a total of 100,000 lire. At the bottom, the date 26 January 1978 is handwritten. The first research step is to read what the paper actually records: a membership receipt.[6]
The written amount, name and purpose are documentary facts; they must not be conflated with other financial transactions. Reconstructing financing requires identification of the parties, direction of transfer, legal basis, timing and use of the funds. VERHO's strength also depends on keeping these objects separate and linking them only when a source supports doing so.
Credit, bills of exchange and control: three different things
On page 120, PDF page 128, the Anselmi majority report names Berlusconi alongside Genghini and Fabbri in a passage concerning support and financing which, according to the commission, was granted beyond normal creditworthiness criteria. This is a statement attributed to that historical report and must be read in its banking context. The 100,000-lire receipt concerns something else: the membership fee.[1]
On page 123, PDF page 131, the same report reconstructs a specific transaction involving Rizzoli: the origin of funds, formal title attributed to Andrea Rizzoli, endorsement of securities, fiduciary deposit and rights affecting decisions. The analytical issue here is the relationship between the named holder and effective control.
In Massimo Teodori's minority report, PDF pages 97–99 reproduce and discuss the agreement of 17 April 1979 between Flaminio Piccoli and Bruno Tassan Din. The schedule records a debt of Editoriale Adige to Rizzoli Finanziaria of 610 million lire backed by bills of exchange. These are liabilities of that corporate and publishing relationship. The text links the financial situation to commitments of political support and intermediation. Its status as a minority report is explicitly preserved.[4]
These materials reveal different levers: entry into an organisation, credit support, bills of exchange as security, separation of formal ownership from control, and mutual dependence between economic and political interests. In the final comparison, they primarily point to families PV/M13, PV/M14 and PV/M16. Their links to VERHO profiles remain classified as partial: the Italian documentary detail expands the reading of the sources without changing the two core findings in Part B.
04 / MethodFollow the mechanism, one step at a time
VERHO is an Antimafia Austria research project devoted to economic and organisational mechanisms and the exercise of public office. The comparison presented here uses a catalogue of 151 profiles: 51 in family D and 100 in family S. The question concerns the entire functioning of a mechanism, from the intended result and decision-making point to the channel used and the effect actually documented.
The parliamentary material was organised into 33 functional families and 88 evidence cards. These also include minority interpretations, programmes, suspicions and counterexamples: a card does not automatically represent a confirmed fact. Part B sets out 71 reasoned matches between this material and VERHO's definitions.[5]
The decisive criterion is the role performed by each step. A personal contact and a digital message may open the same door. A change in eligibility requirements may predetermine the outcome of a selection. A withheld document may prevent another authority from exercising its competence in time. But the object, originator, recipient and consequence must remain identifiable.
What remains, and what changes
Of the 71 explicit matches, Part B distinguishes two matches at the functional core, 55 partial matches, four thematic similarities and ten differences in object or mechanism. These are the results of selected, reasoned comparisons, not 71 independent facts or a percentage validation of the entire model.[5]
| Outcome of explicit matches | Count |
|---|---|
| Match at the functional core | 2 |
| Partial match | 55 |
| Thematic similarity | 4 |
| Difference in object or mechanism | 10 |
Making these distinctions protects the positive result. A request for support does not automatically establish control over all subsequent official acts; a receipt does not become evidence of a different financial flow; a bill of exchange does not equal a payment already made. Each step retains its function and documentary status.
The independence of the comparison must also be described accurately. P2 already appears in the original VERHO catalogue: this is a retrospective comparison, not an entirely blind external validation. Minority reports from the same inquiry do not multiply the number of independent findings. A shared core across Italian and Austrian cases does not prove organisational continuity between them.
One concrete finding remains: in the examined cases, informal intervention in access to office and filtering the flow of information recur over time. The actors and media change; the observed function remains recognisable. To recognise it, we must keep following the trail: from the person to the act, from the amount to its purpose, from the information to its intended recipient. That is where records become public knowledge.
A closer look at the records
15 original pages from Italian and Austrian parliamentary reports. Open a section, select a document and view its enlarged page. The links take you to parliamentary sources.
01Appointments and power5 documents · access to office and personal channels
DOC 01 · P2-0 · PDF 88Appointments and personal channels
The page records interventions in appointments, including a preference that did not materialise.
Appointments and personal channels
The page records interventions in appointments, including a preference that did not materialise.
DOC 02 · AT-R · PDF 184The request for support
Communication of 11 January 2016 concerning the leadership of Salzburg's LVT.
The request for support
Communication of 11 January 2016 concerning the leadership of Salzburg's LVT.
DOC 03 · AT-R · PDF 185Appointment and thanks
Appointment date and subsequent communication; they do not alone reconstruct every causal step.
Appointment and thanks
Appointment date and subsequent communication; they do not alone reconstruct every causal step.
DOC 04 · AT-R · PDF 230The preferred candidate and the limits of the findings
The report distinguishes the candidate's success from proof of professional unsuitability.
The preferred candidate and the limits of the findings
The report distinguishes the candidate's success from proof of professional unsuitability.
DOC 05 · AT-R · PDF 231The limit of the network hypothesis
The report does not specifically examine the wider Hallein-Netzwerk.
The limit of the network hypothesis
The report does not specifically examine the wider Hallein-Netzwerk.
02Information and evidence3 documents · information flows and withholding of information
DOC 06 · P2-0 · PDF 72Intelligence reports not forwarded
The text reproduces an explanation concerning two notes that were not sent to Rome.
Intelligence reports not forwarded
The text reproduces an explanation concerning two notes that were not sent to Rome.
DOC 07 · AT-R · PDF 417Alternative explanations concerning the video
Context and statements on the failure to notify the WKStA.
Alternative explanations concerning the video
Context and statements on the failure to notify the WKStA.
DOC 08 · AT-R · PDF 418The committee's assessment
The page assesses the knowing tolerance of the delay in informing the WKStA.
The committee's assessment
The page assesses the knowing tolerance of the delay in informing the WKStA.
03Finance and control7 documents · P2, credit, bills of exchange and control
DOC 09 · P2-0 · PDF 128The credit passage naming Berlusconi
The name appears in the report's discussion of a network of credit support.
The credit passage naming Berlusconi
The name appears in the report's discussion of a network of credit support.
DOC 10 · P2-0 · PDF 131Formal ownership and control of Rizzoli
Funds, securities, endorsements, fiduciary deposit and influence on corporate decisions.
Formal ownership and control of Rizzoli
Funds, securities, endorsements, fiduciary deposit and influence on corporate decisions.
DOC 11 · P2-0 · PDF 133Shareholdings and control agreements
First part of the report's reconstruction; to be read alongside the next page.
Shareholdings and control agreements
First part of the report's reconstruction; to be read alongside the next page.
DOC 12 · P2-0 · PDF 134Agreements in the P2 reconstruction
Context of the 10.2% holding and transfers involving intermediaries.
Agreements in the P2 reconstruction
Context of the 10.2% holding and transfers involving intermediaries.
DOC 13 · P2-4 · PDF 97Background to the Piccoli–Tassan Din agreement
Teodori minority report; opening of the reproduced agreement dated 17 April 1979.
Background to the Piccoli–Tassan Din agreement
Teodori minority report; opening of the reproduced agreement dated 17 April 1979.
DOC 14 · P2-4 · PDF 98Schedule of debts and bills of exchange
Minority report: entry of 610 million lire in bills of exchange for Editoriale Adige/Rizzoli Finanziaria.
Schedule of debts and bills of exchange
Minority report: entry of 610 million lire in bills of exchange for Editoriale Adige/Rizzoli Finanziaria.
DOC 15 · P2-4 · PDF 99Political support and intermediation
Continuation of the text and interpretation expressly attributed to Teodori.
Political support and intermediation
Continuation of the text and interpretation expressly attributed to Teodori.
Sources for verification
- Parliamentary commission of inquiry into the P2 Masonic lodge, majority report, chair Tina Anselmi, 1984.PDF pages 72, 88, 128, 131 and 133–134; for the first four, printed pages 64, 80, 120 and 123.
- ÖVP Corruption Committee of Inquiry, report 1996 d.B., XXVII legislative period, 2023.PDF pages 184–185 and 229–231: appointments, assessment and limits of the findings.
- Same Austrian report, access to information about the video.PDF pages 417–418, printed pages 414–415.
- P2 Commission, minority report by Massimo Teodori, 1984.PDF pages 97–99: Piccoli–Tassan Din agreement, debts and bills of exchange.
- Antimafia Austria / Pavol Pribela, final editions of 17 November 2026.Parliamentary investigations: functional mechanisms and their recurrence, 240 pp.; Part B, Intersections of Mechanisms, 92 pp., with the comparative XLSX matrix. These are the sole reference editions for the findings summarised here.
- Receipt made out to Berlusconi Silvio: reproduction supplied by the author and cross-checked against the Wikimedia Commons catalogue.Number 104; total 100,000 lire; handwritten date 26 January 1978. The Commons entry states provenance from the Sindona Commission; the original's precise archival location has not been verified for this edition.
Research versions.The comparison relies exclusively on the final editions dated 17 November 2026: the 240-page parliamentary corpus and 92-page Part B, together with its matrix. The Italian visual material does not change the Part B results.
Opening of hearings by the ÖVP Corruption Committee of Inquiry, Vienna, 2 March 2022. View of the hearing room.© Parlamentsdirektion / Thomas Topf. Use for political information and civic education in accordance with the Austrian Parliament's terms.
Arrival of documents for the Austrian parliamentary inquiry, March 2022. The trolley reads “Alles auf den Tisch!” (“Everything on the table!”). Archive title: Eintreffen der Unterlagen.© Parlamentsdirektion / Michael Buchner. Use for political information and civic education in accordance with the Austrian Parliament's terms.
Tina Anselmi, official portrait from 1968, predating the P2 Commission's work.Camera dei deputati / dati.camera.it, via Wikimedia Commons. CC BY-SA 4.0; image reproduced without substantive alteration. https://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-sa/4.0/
Receipt no. 104 in the name Berlusconi Silvio: total 100,000 lire; handwritten date 26 January 1978.Reproduction provided by the author; same digital copy catalogued by Commons, Alessio / Flickr. Commons listing: PD-ineligible; transfer from Flickr verified under CC BY 2.0. Stated provenance: Sindona Commission; the archival original was not directly collated.
Terms of use for Austrian Parliament photographs. The photographs illustrate the context of parliamentary proceedings; the people pictured are not thereby associated with the individual acts being analysed.
Authorial, editorial and scientific responsibility: Pavol Pribela / Antimafia Austria. Analytical and editorial assistance:Watson, AI assistant, not a human co-author.


